Luke Cuenco 04.04.25
I’m the type who always has a knife within reach—whether I’m dialing in a scope at the range, pitching a tent in the backcountry, trekking a muddy trail, or wrestling with a project in the garage for hours, I’ll typically have some sort of blade within arm’s reach. Is it because I’m paranoid? No. Rather, I just know knives come in handy in a lot of ways throughout the day, so it’s best to always have one available should the need arise. In a more serious context, a reliable and sharp blade is also important for your safety and efficiency, no matter the task. I recently got the opportunity to try out the Muddy SWAP Replace-A-Blade Knife. I’ve seen these things advertised on the internet for a while and ever since I first heard of them, I was intrigued. Now, after giving it a solid run, over the last few months, I’ve got plenty to say—it’s earned a place in my gear, but it’s not without a few quirks, and it may not be the perfect blade for everyone. Today I’ll tell you why.
Knife Coverage on AllOutdoor
AllOutdoor Review: Why the Muddy SWAP is My New Favorite Truck Knife
The Muddy SWAP knife is clearly geared more towards the hunting/fishing/camping crowd with its bright safety orange handle. It’s loud, sure, but practical if you’re busy cutting line, preparing a camp meal, or cutting up cardboard boxes and need to set the knife down a lot. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve misplaced a knife in tall grass or on a cluttered workbench. The glass-filled nylon (GFN) handle feels rugged, with a textured, grippy surface that has some grip to it, but becomes quite slippery when exposed to moisture – I’ve decided that I’m going to hand stipple mine to give it some better texturing.
The 3.5-inch drop-point blades, of which there are 5 in the box, are made from 420J2 stainless steel. The blades are very sharp, bordering on razor blade sharpness, but have much better rigidity, giving you enough stiffness to cut through thicker materials without the blade flexing too much. The whole package overall looks and feels well-sized for a range of jobs, from precision cuts to light prying.
Muddy touts the SWAP as a versatile workhorse, and the patent-pending replaceable blade system is the big draw. When the edge dulls, you don’t sharpen it—you swap it out for a fresh one in seconds. It’s a lock-back folder with an ambidextrous pocket clip and lanyard hole, available in a few setups (3 blades, 5 blades, or 5 blades with a pouch). Replacement blade packs are sold separately, which is great for someone like me who’s always finding new ways to wear out a knife and hasn’t yet invested in a fancy sharpening solution like a Ken Onion. Overall, my first impression of the knife is good, and at $50 for the five-blade kit with a belt pouch, I think it’s already worth a try if you like to have different blades around for various tasks.
Blade System: Swappable Knife Blades?
Swapping blades isn’t a novel idea – most of us have probably done it with box cutters or something similar. The SWAP’s interchangeable blade setup is its calling card, and it’s slick and truly quick once you’ve done it a handful of times, and best of all, instead of a razor-thin and razor-sharp razor blade, you get a more universally useful drop-point blade. The blade slides onto a spine and locks with a firm push; hit the release to swap it out. It’s fast, secure, and intuitive—I never worried about it coming loose, even when I was pushing it harder than intended. The 420J2 steel is a practical pick—tough, rust-resistant, and cheap enough to toss when it’s done. It won’t hold an edge like high-end alloys, but that’s irrelevant when you’ve got spares in your pocket that can be swapped out in a matter of seconds.
That said, there’s room for improvement. Spare blades don’t come with a dedicated holder unless you spring for the pouch kit like mine came. If you’re a weekend warrior and use your SWAP for a truly dirty task, the mechanism tends to get grimy—mud from a trail or grease from the garage—swapping can get sticky until you clean it out. It’s not a dealbreaker, but it can prevent you from seating a blade fulling when replacing it if you’re not paying attention, and that can be both frustrating and potentially dangerous.
Durability and Design: Ready for the Long Haul?
While these days I am not a huge fan of folders, the SWAP feels solid for a $50 one. The GFN handle is inexpensive but it doesn’t feel cheap, and the lock-back design held firm under pressure. The pocket clip is thankfully not only made out of flexible enough steel, but it’s also reversible for left or right side but unfortunately not tip up or tip down. Although, in my case, the knife has made its permanent home in the driver-side door of my truck along with my gloves.
At 4 ounces, it’s light without feeling cheap, and the blades can take a decent amount of work-related abuse, like cutting through cardboard, making kindling, or scraping rust, without breaking, but if you try to do anything beyond that with these relatively thin blades they’re liable to snap or at the very least wear away prematurely. The SWAP isn’t a knife for the end of days, you wouldn’t split logs with it—but it’s not meant to be. For bouncing between outdoor jaunts and home fixes, it’s got the durability to keep up and is affordable enough to justify the novelty in my opinion. Keep the blade slot clean, and a fresh blade in the handle and it’ll stay reliable.
Before I wrap up, let’s weigh the good and the not-so-good:
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Replaceable Blades: Swapping in a fresh edge is fast and keeps you working—huge for efficiency outdoors or at home.
- Visibility: That blaze-orange handle is a lifesaver when you drop it in the wild or on a messy workbench.
- Versatility: Handles everything from camp chores to garage tasks with ease – could also come in handy for hunting, fishing, and boating as well.
- Lightweight: At 4 ounces, it’s easy to carry anywhere without weighing you down.
- Affordable: Priced at $40-$60, it’s a solid value for the feature
Cons
- Handle Comfort: Knife is on the smaller side, so great for short tasks – lacks good stippling for wet hands
- Basic Steel: 420J2 is fine, but won’t wow anyone who loves premium blades.
- Blade Storage: No standard holder for spares unless you get the pouch version.
- Mechanism Maintenance: Dirt or grime can gum up the swap system if you’re not careful.
My Final Thoughts: Is It Worth the $50?
The Muddy SWAP is a near-perfect do-everything blade that I’d wholeheartedly recommend to anyone curious about camping or hunting gadgets, as well as those seeking a dependable knife to toss into a tool, tackle, or truck box for whenever the need arises. Its replaceable blade system is what makes it perfect for these away-from-home situations, saving time whether I’m prepping camp or cutting a rope to tie something into the bed of my truck. Lightweight, highly visible, and rugged enough to handle range days, hikes, and garage projects, this knife, at $40 to $60, delivers unbeatable value for everyday outdoor and handyman tasks. It’s an ideal grab-and-go option for your boat, plane, truck, or RV, eliminating the need to sharpen a slew of blades stashed all over the place.
The knife isn’t perfect or even fancy by any metric, the handle could be beefier for comfort during long cuts or frequent use, and replacement blades might cost more over time than sharpening a traditional knife. At home, with a full shop or garage at hand, I’d still reach for my trusty EDC instead. But those are minor gripes for the sheer convenience it offers on the road. The steel won’t wow a true blade snob, and it’s not built to replace a hefty fixed blade for big jobs, but for gear enthusiasts dipping their toes into camping or hunting tools, or anyone wanting a solid, no-fuss knife ready when they need it, the Muddy SWAP is a must-have. It’s already made itself a permanent home in my truck—and I bet it’ll be in yours too.
Trending Products
